Skip to main content

Eli Manning made the right decision in 2004





Way back in 2004 before the NFL Draft, all the buzz surrounded Eli Manning and the ultimatum he gave to the San Diego Chargers, I won't play for you, pulling a John Elway trying to avoid being selected by a disfuncional franchise and despite being officially picked by San Diego it didn't take very long until they shipped him off to the Giants for Phillip Rivers and a bunch of picks.

Now here we are almost two decades later, Eli Making recently announced his retirement and the future surrounding Phillip Rivers is completely unknown, he recently moved his family to Florida.

The scenario each one of them is facing right now illustrates why Manning made the right decision by opting not to play for the Chargers.

It's easy to look at the two Superbowls and say everything worked out for him, but playing in San Diego hasn't been the worst thing in the world over the last 15 years, they probably had more talent than the Giants over that period, definitely more offensive talent. Eli never had a running back like Ladainian Tomlinson he never had a Tight end like Antonio Gates and even without winning the Super Bowl then Chargers bave been consistently present in the playoffs.

A completely illogical hypothetical is that if Eli doesn't demand a trade and plays to the same level he did in his career both in the regular season and in the playoffs, the Chargers have at least one Super Bowl. The truth is nobody knows what would really happen but it's not that risky of a lot.

My point is that it's not like Eli Manning avoided playing for the Browns, but looking beyond the gridiron you see even more clearly why he made the right decision.

The last years for Eli with New York weren't exactly moments to remember, a lot of disappointing campaigns and subpar play from the former number one overall pick, being benched for Geno Smith even if for only a game, losing his starting spot in 2019 to Daniel Jones after just a couple of games, despite all of that the ending for the two time Super Bowl MVP came with class, dignity and all the respect he deserves. John Mara made sure he was honoured properly and his jersey was retired basically on the spot.

Phillip Rivers is also facing an ending in San Diego whether it happens this year or in the next remains unclear the important fact to take notice is that for a variety of reasons there is no proper send-off, for a player that can still contribute and probably wants to keep playing there is no signal that they'd like to resign him, like you are seeing in New Orleans for instance, there is no signal that they will be moving on from Rivers just to get it out of the way and pay tribute to his career. The front office and ownership for the Chargers seem to be frustrated with their Quarterback and dragging this situation for a long time. The horrible move to relocate killed the fanbase which also really diminished the support and recognition for the NC State product.

The bottom line is the level of appreciation both players are receiving right now is very different, too different when you look at what they both did. Eli won the two Super Bowls but Rivers was better in the regular season, played the most consecutive games other than Brett Favre, think about how much you heard about that streak when it came to Eli but nobody remembers Rivers actually surpassed him, a lot of that has to do with how they are treated by both franchises.

As always feel free to comment and subscribe in order to get email notifications everytime a new post comes out. Leave your comment down below and let me know what you think 

See you guys later

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Picks 21-30 Mock Draft 1.0

Picks 21-30 Mock Draft 1.0 #21 Pick Philadelphia Eagles: WR Justin Jefferson School: LSU.   Year: Junior Carson Wentz broke records in 2019 with the amount of yards he got with minimum contribution at the WR spot. Based on his performance at the Combine, Jefferson jumps a few spots and gets himself into the first round. #22 Pick Buffalo Bills: WR Tee Higgins School: Clemson.  Year: Junior This is the Draft if you are looking for receivers and that's the case for the Bills who'll look to surround Allen with as many tools as possible. #23 Pick New England Patriots: QB Jordan Love School: Utah State.   Year: (RS) Junior I believe Eason could go here and I understand that Love isn't the type of QB prospect Belichick usually goes for but baed off what I am hearing in terms of rumors and the lack of weapons Jordan had in his final year. I could see this happening. #24 Pick New Orleans Saints: CB Kristian Fulton School: LSU.  ...

Reviewing Super Bowl LIV

For the rest of your life don't ever let anybody tell you that you couldn't do it because you did it. The famous quote by Bill Parcels after his first Super Bowl victory against the Denver Broncos in 1986, so simple yet it's what comes to my mind after seeing Andy Reid lift that trophy in Miami. He is now an all time great coach with no buts, no he was a great coach but he never won the big one. It's easy and maybe right to assume that with Mahomes he'd eventually win one in Kansas City, but with these things you never know, Reid has been a great coach since when and hadn't won, Dan Marino after losing to the 49ers early in his caeer probably felt the same thing and that's not something you care about right now, you just want to win. Before anything let me congratulate Andy Reid, Patrick Mahomes, Brett Veach and the entire Chiefs' roster for a wonderful season that culminated in a championship last night, well deserved. After the Chiefs' com...

Watford took down Liverpool and it wasn't even close

Liverpool finally lost a match in the Premier League, how did it happen? As I listened to Klopp's interview after the match there was something very interesting that he touched on. When asked how would the team react after losing, he mentioned that the Reds lost matches this year in the Champins League and that the feeling of defeat while rare isn't something that they haven't experienced this season. He isn't really worried about that. To be honest with you there are a lot of teams in this battle against relegation that play an interesting brand of football, clubs like Brighton and Southampton with an interesting philosophy as a whole. Watford's management is the most impatient in the Premier League with little to no believe in continuity, but as much as that can disappoint me as an analyst, the fans of the club aren't really responsible for it and ultimately they are the ones that suffer the most when the club underachieves. While Pearson has done a...